Post #3: The identity of the Amish
An interesting takeaway from
searching these images is that they only show mainly JUST Amish men or women.
Unless if it is a “family” photo where there is the husband, wife and children,
the images usually separate the gender in the society. I had mentioned in my
last blog. This particular community of believers is highlighted by the media
to a separation in gender. However, I believe that that the separation of
genders is a belief that the Amish value.
The style of clothing that the
Amish are seen wearing has been depicted in these memes. Whether it is the
typical, two button, jean and hat attire or if it is a long conservative dress
with the hiking boots for women, these images are shown. In the meme with the
two “Amish” (I use quotes because these men are probably not Amish but fit the
mold of what a typical Amish believer looks like)) men at the coffee shop, they
are wearing the typical outfit an Amish member would be wearing.
Since technology is not a part of
this community, the media, through its memes, frames the Amish based on their
beliefs. One of the ways the media does this is through a “playful” frame. This
is a lighthearted motivation to explain beliefs in a certain community. For
example, the meme with the man who doesn’t know what a turn signal is, the meme
is playfully showing that the Amish do not have an advanced use of technology.
The meme with the men at the coffee shop shows one man with his hands on his
head. This can be seen as a “relaxed” or a “cool” boast acting like “Before it
was put on Facebook, I played Farmville”. These playful memes characterize the
Amish into their own identity. This identity portrayed by the media through
these memes and are now becoming more and more of an “authentic” characters
online like Dr. Campbell stated in her book Digital
Religion
With the conservative clothing, it
is a big value in the community because the Amish are portrayed as a community
that does not want to believe in “progressivism”. They stick to their old
traditions and live by those. Going back to the same meme, the wording states
that the men played Farmville (a Facebook game that has the user control and
run their own farms) before it was on Facebook. Since technology is growing and
the Amish aren’t seen as a progressive society, the meme represents a boast
that the Amish can claim since they don’t use technology to play a game about
farming but rather are farming for a living.
Through these observations, we have
seen how the Amish are shown in the media through memes and through these memes
how they handle technology. We have seen the “playful” wording that is
presented in the memes to show a certain identity that the Amish present. These
memes are highlighted throughout the internet to show who the Amish are. They
are framed by the media as a non-progressive, conservative culture who don’t
know how to use the technology that the 21st century offer. They
rely on dated technology to keep their community going. Due to their use of
media, they (Amish) have an identity that this culture of memes will use in
generations to come.
https://turtleboysports.com/the-amish-teen-arrested-for-dui-driving-with-friends-on-hood-of-horse-and-buggy-will-be-an-amish-legend-for-years-to-come/
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/1nfm
I agree with you and that I believe that the popularity of these memes are due to the fact that having an attribute as a community of not understanding technology, something that is ingrained in our society today, is an easy target to ridicule.
ReplyDeleteIt will be important for you to contextualize your observation about the Amish with scholarly work on how they have historically been portrayed within popular media. Consider sources such as, The Amish and the media by DZ Umble & DL Weaver-Zercher.
ReplyDelete